PS 92: Introduction to Comparative Politics

Course Guidelines and Syllabus

Instructor: Diana Morlang office: Perkins 02CG
dmorlang@duke.edu office phone: 660-4334

Comparative politics, by tradition, seeks to explain differences between political systems and countries various routes to democracy. This course will explore the politics in five regions. Part I explores in depth the political institutions in Western European democracies; this material will provide a basis for comparing the political process in other regions as well as highlight the differences between parliamentary democracy and presidential democracy (as in the US). Part II explores two regions that are transitioning to western-style democracies. First, we explore the legacy of colonialism in Latin America, and countries' attempts to establish stable political systems. Next we examine the transitions from communism to democracy in East and Central Europe. Part III looks at three regions that have not tried to follow the western model. We look at political culture and institutions in Asia, and Africa, and evaluate their different approaches to politics and their success at providing stability. Throughout the course, we will compare the experiences of individual countries and regions, and explore the conditions for variation in political development. Along with required readings in texts that provide background information and theoretical explanations, students will read the New York Times daily and analyze current events using material discussed in class.

Assignments and Requirements:

Reading Assignments should be completed before class, and students will be expected to discuss them. This also applies to the New York Times; students should look at the day’s paper before class and be prepared to discuss the events in connection with class material.

At the end of each week there will be a current event quiz at the beginning of class. The quizzes will require short answers about major stories covered in the NY Times during that week.

Exams follow parts I and II of the class. The exams will require short essay answers to questions about readings, lectures and discussions covered in that section of course and the relationship between specific cases and course-wide theories. There is no final exam for the class, but the final paper includes the material covered in part III.

Students will write a final paper, due the last day of class (August 12). This assignment requires students to research the current political system in a country from Africa or Asia. The first part of the paper requires students to discuss general political trends in Africa and Asia using course readings and discussions. The second part of the paper requires students to describe the political system of the country and relate its experiences with democracy to those of the region overall. Students will present and discuss their projects in class August 11 or 12. More detailed guidelines will be provided later in the course. The class will have an introduction to library research.

Participation is an important part of this class. Not only will students be assigned to specific in-class activities such as paper presentations, but daily class discussions are also important. Students are expected to raise questions about readings and to explore how theory and cases go together.

Grading:

Current Event Quizzes 12%

Exams 50% (25% each exam)

Research Paper 25%

Participation 13% (including presentation)

Required Texts:

Bratton, Michael and Nicolas van de Walle. 1997. Democratic Experiments in Africa: Regime Transitions in Comparative Perspective. New York Cambridge University Press.

Gallagher, Michael, Michael Laver and Peter Mair. 1995. Representative Government in Modern Europe. New York: McGraw Hill.

White, Stephan, Judy Batt, Paul G. Lewis. 1998. Developments in Central and Eastern European Politics, 2nd Edition. Durham: Duke University Press.

Skidmore, Thomas E. and Peter H. Smith. 1997. Modern Latin America. New York: Oxford University Press.

A packet of required articles costing $5 will be prepared by the instructor and distributed in class.

The New York Times. Students can purchase (or share) a subscription and pick papers up at a central drop-box (see attached form), or read daily in the newspaper reading room in the basement of Perkins Library.

Syllabus

Introduction

Tuesday July 6: Introduction to course requirements and the theme of the class

Wednesday July 7: What is democracy?

Samuel Huntington "What?" chapter 1 in The Third Wave, Democratization in the Late Twentieth Century Norman: University of Oklahoma Press, 1991, 1-30.
 
 

Part I. Politics in Industrial Democracies Thursday July 8: Political Leadership

Gallagher Chapters 2, 3

Friday July 9: Parties

Gallagher Chapter 7-8

Current events quiz 1

Monday July 12: What does voting mean in a democracy?

Gallagher Chapters 9, 11
 
 

Tuesday July 13: Building Coalition Governments

Gallagher Chapter 12

Wednesday July 14: Economic Policy

Gallagher Chapters 13, 14

Thursday July 15: Mid-term Exam #1.

Part II. Transitions to democracy

Transition from Authoritarianism: Latin America

Friday July 16: Latin American legacies

Skidmore Prologue and Chapter 2

Current events quiz 2

Monday July 19: Political Institutions in Latin America

Skidmore Chapters 3 and 4

Tuesday July 20: Transitions from Authoritarianism

Skidmore Chapters 5, 7 and Epilogue

Wednesday July 21: Economic Development and case studies

Skidmore Chapter 11

Simulation

Thursday July 22: Presidentialism and Parliamentarism

Scott Mainwaring and Timothy R. Scully "Conclusion" in Building Democratic Institutions: Party Systems in Latin America, Stanford University Press, Stanford, 1995.

Juan J. Linz "The Perils of Presidentialism" Journal of Democracy 1990:1.

Arturo Valenzuela "Latin America: Presidentialism in Crisis" Journal of Democracy 1993:4.

Transition from Communism: Eastern Europe Friday July 23: Legacies of Communism

Katherine Verdery "What Was Socialism and Why Did It Fail?" Contention 3:1 Fall 1993, 1-23.

White, chapter 11

Current events quiz 3

Monday July 26: Transition to Democratic Rule and case studies

White Chapters 2-4

Tuesday July 27: Democratic Institutions: Parties, Electoral Systems, Presidents

White Chapters 7-9

Gallagher chapter 15

Wednesday July 28: The Problems of Simultaneous Economic and Political Transition

White Chapters 10, 14

Thursday July 29: Comparing Latin America and Eastern Europe

Joan Nelson, "How Market Reforms and Democratic Consolidation Affect Each Other" in Intricate Links: Democratic and Market Reforms in Latin America and Eastern Europe, New Brunswick: Transaction Publishers, 1994, 1-36.

Friday July 30: Mid-term Exam #2

Current events quiz 4

Part III: Government and Politics in Asia and Africa Monday August 2: Asian Political Traditions

Steven Hood, "The Myth of Asian-Style Democracy" Asian Survey September 1998, 853-866.

Muthiah Alagappa, "The Asian Spectrum" Journal of Democracy 6:1, 1995, 29-36.

Gerald Curtis, "For Democratic Development" Journal of Democracy 8:3, 1997, 139-145.

Tuesday August 3: State and Economy United

Mark Thompson, "Late Industrializers, Late Democratizers: Developmental States in the Asia-Pacific" Third World Quarterly, 17:4 1996, 625-647.

Wednesday August 4: Chinese Transition to Democracy?

Minxin Pei, "Creeping Democratization in China" Journal of Democracy 6:1, 1995, 65-79.

Michel Oksenberg, "Confronting a Classic Dilemma" Journal of Democracy 9:1, 1998, 27-34.

Thursday August 5: Political Institutions in Africa

Bratton Chapter 2

Friday August 6: The Challenges of Democracy in Africa

Bratton Chapter 3 and 6

Current events quiz 5

Monday August 9: Africa in Comparative Perspective

Bratton Chapter 7

Tuesday August 10: The Future of Democracy

Robert Kaplan "Was Democracy Just a Moment?" The Atlantic Monthly December 1997, 55-80.

Samuel Huntington, "Democracy for the Long Haul" Journal of Democracy 7:2, 1996, 3-13.

Simulation: UN Task Force for developing democratic institutions in Kosovo.

Wednesday August 11: presentations

Thursday August 12: All papers due at the start of class.

Current Events Quiz 6