The Meiji Restoration

 

Discussion Questions:

  1. Was the Meiji Restoration a revolution or just a changing of the guard?

  2. What was the role of the Emperor?

  3. Could the Shogunate have survived?

Lecture Notes:

Click here to see "The Meiji Restoration" Lecture

 

TIMELINE

1853

US Commodore Perry arrives in Uraga with four warships. Demands opening of Japan for supplying foreign ships.


1854

Perry returns with seven warships. Japan is forced to sign Treaty of Amity. Similar treaties immediately demanded by Russia and England. Japan opens ports of Shimoda and Hakodate to foreign ships.

1856

Townsend Harris takes up residence in Shimoda as US Consul General.


1857

Harris concludes trade treaty with bakufu. Includes opening of more ports, rights of extraterritoriality, fixed tariffs on trade.

1858

Emperor refuses to ratify treaty. Demands expulsion of foreigners. Bakufu ratifies treaty without imperial consent, and concludes similar treaties with Britain, Holland, Russia, and France.

1859

Trade begins in Kanagawa (Yokohama), Nagasaki, Hakodate. Shogunal chief minister Ii Naosuke begins purge of critics

1860

First Japanese embassy travels to US. Ii Naosuke assassinated. American embassy interpreter Heusken murdered. Inflation causes rice riots

1861

Shogun Iemochi marries Emperor’s daughter – attempted “union of court and shogunate”

1862

British trader Richardson murdered by Satsuma retainers. Britain demands 100,000 pounds indemnity. Abandonment of “sankin kotai” system of alternate attendance.

1863

Following imperial order to expel foreigners, Choshu bombards British, French and Dutch ships in strait of Shimonoseki. Britain mounts expedition against Satsuma, bombards and burns capital city of Kagoshima

1864

Allied force (Britain, France, US, Holland) attacks and burns city of Shimonoseki in reprisal for previous year’s bombardment. Choshu attacks shogunal forces in Kyoto. Shogun orders punitive expedition against Choshu. Choshu forces retire and leaders accept punishment.

1865

Bakufu orders second punitive expedition against Choshu. Choshu fights back, leading to military stalemate.

1866

Shogun Iemochi dies – his death is used as an excuse to end the Choshu campaign. Tokugawa Yoshinobu becomes new Shogun. Immediately – but too late – initiates major reforms.

1867

Faced with united opposition, Yoshinobu resigns as Shogun and “returns power to the court”. Combined forces of Satsuma and Choshu attack shogunal army

1868

Collapse of Tokugawa bakufu. Emperor Meiji moves to Edo (renamed Tokyo). Charter Oath calls for abolition of “absurd customs” and seeking of foreign knowledge.

 

POWERPOINT OUTLINE (Presented in Class):

Decline of the Tokugawa Bakufu
- Stresses within samurai class
     o Paradox of warrior ruling class in time of peace
     o Impoverishment due to fixed rice incomes
- Financial problems of bakufu (shogunate) and domains
     o Fixed incomes unable to keep up with rising prices and living standards
     o Growing relative wealth of merchants/townsmen (and even some peasants)
     o Inability to reform tax systems
- Growing foreign threat – industrial technology + imperialism
- Issues of legitimacy – calls for “restoration” of imperial power

Rise of Revolutionary Fervor
- Ancient enmity of southwestern domains
     o Revival of Choshu and Satsuma
- Anti-foreign sentiment – rise of the “men of high purpose”
     o Nascent nationalism
- Popularity of emperor-centered “national learning”
- Frustration of lower-ranked samurai
- Need for unified nation to counter foreign threat
     o Ideal of “Western science and Eastern ethics”

Military Conflict
- Race to import Western military techniques
     o Ships, guns and cannon
     o Conscript soldiers
- Struggle for control of Kyoto
- Informal alliances with foreign powers
     o Bakufu with France, rebels with Britain
- Failed bakufu attempts to “chastise” rebels

 

IDs:

Matthew Perry
Townsend Harris
Unequal treaties

Satsuma
Choshu

Tokugawa Yoshinobu

Okubo Toshimichi
Saigo Takamori
Ito Hirobumi
Charter oath


Notes on IDs:

Tokugawa Yoshinobu (the last Shogun)

Emperor Mutsuhito (=Meiji)

Commodore Matthew Perry (U.S. naval officer who led mission to Japan in 1853-4)

Townsend Harris (first American consul to Japan; instigator of unequal treaties)

Satsuma: a domain in Kyushu, southern Japan, traditionally hostile to the Tokugawa

Chōshū: a domain in southwest Honshu, also hostile to the Tokugawa

 

 

Additional reading:

The classic work is William Beasley, The Meiji Restoration (Stanford, 1972) – all 600 pages of it. See also:

Harold Bolitho, “The Meiji Restoration” in Wray, Harry; Conroy, Hilary, eds. Japan Examined: perspectives on modern Japanese history. Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press, 1983. 411p. 1983 59-65

Nagai, Michio; Urrutia, Miguel, eds. Meiji Ishin: restoration and revolution. Tokyo: United Nations University, 1985

Marius Jansen. Sakamoto Ryoma and the Meiji restoration. Stanford, Stanford UP 1971

George Wilson, “Pursuing the millennium in the Meiji Restoration” in Najita, Tetsuo; Koschmann, J. Victor, eds. Conflict in Modern Japanese History: the neglected tradition. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton UP, 1982. 456p. 1982 177-194

Akamatsu, Paul. Meiji, 1868; revolution and counter-revolution in Japan. Translated from the French by Miriam Kochan. New York, Harper & Row [1972]

Craig, Albert M. Choshu in the Meiji restoration. Cambridge, Harvard University Press, 1967,c1961.

Harootunian, Harry D. Toward restoration; the growth of political consciousness in Tokugawa Japan. Berkeley, University of California Press, 1970.

Totman, Conrad D. The collapse of the Tokugawa bakufu, 1862-1868. Honolulu : University Press of Hawaii, c1980.

Walthall, Anne. The weak body of a useless woman : Matsuo Taseko and the Meiji Restoration. Chicago, Ill. : University of Chicago Press, 1998 (an account of a female poet’s experience of the revolution)

Also see Episode 1 of the documentary series The Pacific Century (in Lilly)

Chapter 12 (pages 339 to 383) of Shimazaki Toson, Before the Dawn translated by William E. Naff. Honolulu : University of Hawaii Press, c1987.

Remembering Aizu : the testament of Shiba Goro / edited by Ishimitsu Mahito ; translated, with introduction & notes, by Teruko Craig. Honolulu : University of Hawai`i Press, c1999